A Model of Consistency

Mike Mussina debuts on BBWAA Hall of Fame ballot

December 03, 2013
2014 Hall of Fame candidate Mike Mussina. (Photo File/NBHOF Library)

Consistently consistent. 

While that may be the way Hall of Famer Yogi Berra would depict Mike Mussina, it also accurately describes the way Mussina played the game. 

Mussina retired from the game of baseball in 2008 – after recording 270 wins in his 18-year career. A model of consistency, Mussina logged 17 seasons of 10-plus wins. 

“To ask if I should be compared to Greg Maddux or to [Tom] Glavine or anybody that’'s played in this era, that in itself is an honor,” Mussina said. 

“People are going to talk about [my Hall of Fame chances] any number of ways. I'm just glad that I've achieved enough and made enough of an impression that people are going to include me in the conversation.” 

Mussina debuts on the Baseball Writers’ Association of America Hall of Fame ballot this fall. He is one of 36 players on the 2014 BBWAA ballot for the Class of 2014. 

“There's no question in my mind he's a Hall of Famer,” Yankees General Manager Brian Cashman said. “Some people say 300 wins is an automatic plateau. What he did to get 270 total wins, with all those things combined – in a division where the Red Sox and Yankees have been slugging it out ... [in] the toughest division in baseball for at least a decade – I just think it has been spectacular for the length and consistency. He's one of the all-timers.” 

BBWAA members who have at least 10 years of tenure with the organization can vote in the election, and the results will be announced Jan. 8. Any candidate who receives at least 75 percent of all BBWAA votes cast will be enshrined in the Hall of Fame as part of the Class of 2014. The Induction Ceremony will be held July 27 in Cooperstown. 

Growing up in Montoursville, Pa., Michael Cole Mussina was a three-sport athlete in high school, as he starred on the basketball court and the football field, but he was at his best on the pitcher’s mound. 

[Scouting reports on Mike Mussina]

He was drafted out of high school by the Baltimore Orioles in the 11th round of the 1987 Draft. However, Mussina nixed the Orioles’ offer in favor of Stanford University, where he enrolled and played the game he loved. 

At Stanford, Mussina continued to excel. In three years, he won more than 25 games and was a key contributor on the 1988 Cardinal team that won the NCAA National Championship – he was named the Most Valuable Freshman on the 1988 squad. 

Although years had passed, the Orioles did not give up on pursuing Mussina and finally got their guy, as he was drafted by Baltimore again, this time with the 20th pick in the first round of the 1990 Major League Baseball Draft. Mussina decided to forgo his final year at Stanford and sign with the Orioles. Ultimately Baltimore proved to be a great landing spot for Mussina, as the Inner Harbor is located only about three hours from his hometown. 

It didn’t take long for “Moose” to make his debut with the big league team in Baltimore. After only 28 appearances in the minors, Mussina made his MLB debut on Aug. 4, 1991, giving up just one run on four hits in 7.2 innings. 

Mussina quickly established himself as a household name at the Major League level. In his first full season – 1992 – Moose won 18 games and finished with a 2.54 ERA. He was selected to the AL All-Star team and finished fourth in Cy Young Award balloting. 

In the strike-shortened season of 1995, Mussina led the American League in wins with 19. His ERA of 3.29 was fourth in the league.  

As Mussina continued to advance his career, the Baltimore Orioles progressed as well. After the Orioles finished the 1995 season near .500, 1996 signaled the start of what would be Baltimore’s first back-to-back postseason run since the 1973-74 seasons. 

Mussina led Baltimore to two straight AL Championship Series appearances in 1996 and 1997. In six postseason starts over the two years, he logged a 2-1 record with a 2.53 ERA, striking out 53 batters in 42.2 innings pitched. 

After spending his first 10 years at the MLB level with the Orioles, Mussina signed with the New York Yankees in the fall of 2000 as a free agent. He left behind a legacy in Baltimore, leaving the Charm City with 147 wins – third in Baltimore’s history – while his 1,535 strikeouts rank second all-time in the Oriole annals. 

In the Bronx, Mussina would help form one of the more formidable rotations put together in recent years. In his eight seasons, Moose would pitch alongside many Yankee greats including the likes of Roger Clemens, Andy Pettitte, David Wells and Randy Johnson. 

The Yankees would win two AL Championships with Mussina on the club. In 2001 – his first season with the Bronx Bombers – the Yankees would fall in seven games to the Arizona Diamondbacks in the World Series. 

Mussina was a key catalyst in 2001’s deep postseason run. He won three of his four starts, retiring 21 batters via the strikeout and recording a 2.63 ERA over 24 innings pitched in the four-game stretch. 

In the 2003 season, Mussina won 17 games – a feat he accomplished eight times in his career – and led New York’s starting rotation in ERA with a 3.40. In the process, he helped the Bronx Bombers bring another AL Pennant to Yankee Stadium, but this time the Yankees would fall in the World Series to the NL Champion Florida Marlins, in six games. 

All in all, out of the eight seasons Mussina donned the famous Yankee Pinstripes, the team would win six AL East titles and appear in the MLB Playoffs seven times. 

After a sub-par 2007, Mussina bounced back in 2008 with one of the best seasons a 39-year-old pitcher has ever compiled. The man with a degree in economics from Stanford used his veteran prowess and his pinpoint accuracy to will batters out, rather than try to overpower them as he did earlier in his career. 

“Mike’s a great competitor,” former Baltimore teammate Cal Ripken said. “He makes great pitches when he has to. And he makes adjustments.” 

He developed and threw more pitches – and variability within those pitches to get the job done – so much he drew some big comparisons from his former manager, Joe Torre: “[Juan Marichal] is the guy that comes to mind, a guy being able to throw a lot of pitches at different angles and throw strikes at any time.” 

Finality to his Yankees career – and career in baseball – did not come without fireworks. In Mussina’s final season, he recorded his first 20-win season – something he had been ever so close to his whole career, finishing with 19 wins twice. Mussina’s final stat line in 2008 read like he was nearing the precipice of his career, not the end: 20-9 with a 3.37 ERA. 

In his final game, Moose went six innings and did not allow a run against arch-rival Boston. He got the win and in the process became the oldest first-time 20-game winner.  

Mussina was a figure of consistency in baseball over two different decades. He won at least 10 games in each of his 17 full seasons and recorded 11 15-win seasons. “You have to watch him every fifth day to appreciate how good he has been and how consistent he has been,” said Torre. 

Moose ended his career with 270 wins, tied for 33rd on the all-time list, while his 2,813 strikeouts rank 19th in MLB history. He was a five-time All-Star and won seven Gold Glove Awards. 

“It was a great pleasure playing against – and even more so – with Mike Mussina since I entered the league in 1995,” said former teammate Derek Jeter. “He was a true professional both on and off the field. Moose's accomplishments in the game over the last 18 years represent a Hall of Fame player.” 

Year Age Tm W L W-L% ERA G GS GF CG SHO IP H R ER HR BB SO
1991 22 BAL 4 5 .444 2.87 12 12 0 2 0 87.2 77 31 28 7 21 52
1992 23 BAL 18 5 .783 2.54 32 32 0 8 4 241.0 212 70 68 16 48 130
1993 24 BAL 14 6 .700 4.46 25 25 0 3 2 167.2 163 84 83 20 44 117
1994 25 BAL 16 5 .762 3.06 24 24 0 3 0 176.1 163 63 60 19 42 99
1995 26 BAL 19 9 .679 3.29 32 32 0 7 4 221.2 187 86 81 24 50 158
1996 27 BAL 19 11 .633 4.81 36 36 0 4 1 243.1 264 137 130 31 69 204
1997 28 BAL 15 8 .652 3.20 33 33 0 4 1 224.2 197 87 80 27 54 218
1998 29 BAL 13 10 .565 3.49 29 29 0 4 2 206.1 189 85 80 22 41 175
1999 30 BAL 18 7 .720 3.50 31 31 0 4 0 203.1 207 88 79 16 52 172
2000 31 BAL 11 15 .423 3.79 34 34 0 6 1 237.2 236 105 100 28 46 210
2001 32 NYY 17 11 .607 3.15 34 34 0 4 3 228.2 202 87 80 20 42 214
2002 33 NYY 18 10 .643 4.05 33 33 0 2 2 215.2 208 103 97 27 48 182
2003 34 NYY 17 8 .680 3.40 31 31 0 2 1 214.2 192 86 81 21 40 195
2004 35 NYY 12 9 .571 4.59 27 27 0 1 0 164.2 178 91 84 22 40 132
2005 36 NYY 13 8 .619 4.41 30 30 0 2 2 179.2 199 93 88 23 47 142
2006 37 NYY 15 7 .682 3.51 32 32 0 1 0 197.1 184 88 77 22 35 172
2007 38 NYY 11 10 .524 5.15 28 27 0 0 0 152.0 188 90 87 14 35 91
2008 39 NYY 20 9 .690 3.37 34 34 0 0 0 200.1 214 85 75 17 31 150
18 Yrs 270 153 .638 3.68 537 536 0 57 23 3562.2 3460 1559 1458 376 785 2813

 

Andrew Kivette was the 2013 public relations intern in the Hall of Fame’s Frank and Peggy Steele Internship Program for Youth Leadership Development