99-year-old fan relives baseball memories at Hall of Fame

Written by: Alex Coffey

While walking through the Museum on April 25, 2017, Robert Noonan suddenly paused and motioned at a heavily-worn glove in the Autumn Glory exhibit.

“No wonder Brooks Robinson caught so many,” he said to his tour guide, Senior Curator Tom Shieber. “His pocket was huge!”

Hall of Fame Membership

There is no simpler, and more essential, way to demonstrate your support than to sign on as a Museum Member.

The mitt he was referring to was used by Robinson in the 1970 World Series, during which the third baseman made several fantastic plays, including his iconic backhanded catch and off-balance throw to rob Lee May of a base hit. But Noonan’s recollection of the “Human Vacuum Cleaner” was only one of a treasure trove of memories encapsulated in the mind of a 99-year-old baseball fanatic.

Noonan visited the Museum with two of his sons, Tom Noonan and acclaimed musician Willie Nile. And with the family connection, the visit became a walk down memory lane.

Senior Curator Tom Shieber (right) points out Babe Ruth's final three home runs on May 25, 1935 in the National League day-by-day sheets to Robert Noonan (left) and his son, Willie Nile. (Milo Stewart Jr. / National Baseball Hall of Fame and Museum)

“My dad was born in 1917, he’ll be 100 in November,” Tom Noonan said. “Warren Spahn was born in 1921 so there was a four year age difference between them. My dad played second base for Bennett High School in Buffalo N.Y., and Warren Spahn played for South Park – their rival – which was also in Buffalo. He played against Warren.”

Overhearing the conversation, Robert brought the story to life.

“We played against him but I never batted against him. Lucky me.”

Willie Nile holds Lou Gehrig's first baseman's mitt while visiting the Hall of Fame with his brother Tom Noonan (left) and his father Robert Noonan (center). (Milo Stewart Jr. / National Baseball Hall of Fame and Museum)

But his early encounter with a future Hall of Famer was only the beginning. Growing up in Buffalo, where he still lives, Noonan was a Cardinals fan. The Rochester Red Wings, who were a Red Birds’ minor league affiliate from 1928-1960, played in Buffalo on occasion. So Noonan grew up watching the likes of Rip Collins, Hall of Famer Chick Hafey and of course, Pepper Martin – his favorite player.

“I saw Pepper Martin play for the Rochester Red Wings,” Noonan said. “At that time he played center field. I couldn’t help but notice him because when the inning ended he sprinted from center field into the third base dugout. Every time.”

His knowledge wasn’t limited to the Cardinals’ Gashouse Gang teams of the 1930s, though. As he grew older, Noonan evolved to become a true fan of the National Pastime, rather than of any particular team, a characteristic that became more evident as the tour went on.

Robert Noonan (center) poses with his sons Willie Nile (left) and Tom Noonan (right) while holding Ted Williams' bat. (Milo Stewart Jr. / National Baseball Hall of Fame and Museum)

Noonan had a comment or an aside for just about every artifact shown to him, whether it was Lou Gehrig mitt: “well worn,”; Ted Williams’ bat: “No kidding. Hillerich & Bradsby. He did a lot of hitting with a little stick like that”; or Russ Hodges’s scorecard recording Bobby Thomson hitting his game-winning home run: “Who hasn’t heard of Bobby Thomson?!”

What started as a tour quickly turned into something more meaningful: A bridge between two generations of baseball fans. For with every glove, bat and scorecard came a memory associated with it.

“This is something else,” said Nile, who has performed and recorded with artists including Ringo Starr, Bruce Springsteen and the Barenaked Ladies. “I told a lot of people I was coming here, and they were so excited. I’m definitely going to come back again.”

Noonan, who after a day of walking around the Museum was miraculously more energized than before he arrived, agreed with his son.

“I liked all of the artifacts,” said Noonan. “It’s marvelous that you have all these relics here. The National Pastime is really a wonderful thing.”


Alex Coffey was the communications specialist at the National Baseball Hall of Fame and Museum

Bobby Doerr reflects on a life in baseball

Bobby Doerr was elected to the Hall of Fame in 1986.

Lou Gehrig hits four consecutive home runs

On June 3, 1932, Lou Gehrig hit a home run in his first four at-bats against the Philadelphia Athletics. Though Bobby Lowe and Hall of Famer Ed Delahanty had each hit four home runs in a contest during the 1890s, no one had accomplished the feat before in baseball’s modern era.

Braves legend Warren Spahn is sold to the Mets

Braves' mainstay Warren Spahn was sold to the Mets on Nov. 23, 1964.

Ted Williams Looks Back

The Red Sox legend sat down with Hall of Fame in 2000.

Bobby Doerr reflects on a life in baseball

Bobby Doerr was elected to the Hall of Fame in 1986.

Lou Gehrig hits four consecutive home runs

On June 3, 1932, Lou Gehrig hit a home run in his first four at-bats against the Philadelphia Athletics. Though Bobby Lowe and Hall of Famer Ed Delahanty had each hit four home runs in a contest during the 1890s, no one had accomplished the feat before in baseball’s modern era.

Braves legend Warren Spahn is sold to the Mets

Braves' mainstay Warren Spahn was sold to the Mets on Nov. 23, 1964.

Ted Williams Looks Back

The Red Sox legend sat down with Hall of Fame in 2000.