#CardCorner: 1975 Topps Chris Cannizzaro
Hall of Fame staffers are also baseball fans and love to share their stories. Here is a fan's perspective from Cooperstown.
As we remember Hall of Fame Weekend, my mind invariably turns to the baseball figures we have lost since the last Induction Ceremony. Thoughts of Hall of Famer Jim Bunning and his perfect game on Father’s Day come to mind, as do memories of some of the other players who have died, including Jimmy Piersall, Gene Conley, Anthony Young, and of course, current day players like Jose Fernandez and Yordano Ventura, who passed away long before they should have.
Some of the players we have lost over the last 12 months are less famous on a national scale, but still just as important on a personal level. For me, one of those players was a relatively obscure catcher who spent much of his career as a backup. But his is a name that is known to fans of a certain age, especially those who can remember the dawning days of the New York Mets franchise.
Digital Preservation Project
We need your help to preserve priceless treasures housed here in Cooperstown. Make a gift today to help ensure that fans around the world can have online access to the Museum collections and Library archive.
Chris Cannizzaro was a member of the Mets during their inaugural season of 1962. Seven years later, he made his first and only All-Star team. He was never really a star, but was a good catch-and-throw receiver who played for six different National League teams, handled pitchers well and made himself welcome in the many clubhouses that he visited. He was also a player who appeared on one of the stranger cards that the Topps Gum Company ever produced.
In 1975, Cannizzaro appeared on a Topps card for the final time in his career. The card, which shows him as a member of the San Diego Padres, is just so garish and gaudy, between the bright yellow and powder blue borders and the psychedelic airbrushing of Cannizzaro’s uniform. It looks like the Topps artist mixed some yellow with some brown, splotched the two colors at various points on the photograph, and then added some Crayola to the cap (just for run), while also creating a makeshift “SD.” It’s so revolting, it’s actually good – in a weird 1975 kind of a way.
What’s also interesting about Cannizzaro’ 1975 Topps card is the need to resort to airbrushing in the first place. Cannizzaro played 26 games for the Padres in 1974, and had also played for the team during an earlier stint, so there were opportunities for Topps to acquire photographs of him wearing actual San Diego colors. Somehow an updated photograph of Cannizzaro eluded Topps. And then in 1975, Cannizzaro did not play in the major leagues at all. Opting to go with younger catchers like Fred Kendall and Bob Davis (and veteran ex-Cub Randy Hundley), the Padres assigned Cannizzaro to their Triple-A affiliate, the Hawaii Islanders. For veteran players in the 1970s, there was no better minor league locale than Honolulu. There Cannizzaro served as a player/coach, while also enjoying the beaches and poolside settings of the Hawaiian Islands.
Long before those beaches, Cannizzaro started his minor league career in Decatur, Ill., of the Midwest League. That’s where the St. Louis Cardinals assigned him after first signing him as an amateur ballplayer in 1956. A catcher with a strong throwing arm if spotty receiving skills, Cannizzaro struggled with the bat, hitting only .212 as a Midwest League rookie. But he still managed to make Triple-A by his third season, before being slowed by a stint in the U.S. Army, involving a six-month commitment in 1959.
Cannizzaro made his major league debut for St. Louis at the start of the 1960 season, when manager Solly Hemus included him on the roster as the Cardinals’ fourth-string catcher. (Yes, teams had fourth-string catchers back then, in part because of the rule that allowed teams to start the season with 28 players.) After appearing in a handful of games, Cannizzaro endured a fast demotion to Triple-A Rochester. In 1961, he was supposed to start the season at Triple-A Houston, but did not play a single game there because of what was originally diagnosed as a horrific bout of food poisoning. (It turned out to be appendicitis, requiring surgery.) He missed a month of action, and then received a transfer to Portland, the Cardinals’ new Triple-A affiliate. Remaining there for most of the summer, he finally received a call-up to the Cardinals in August. He played in all of six games, coming to bat only twice. Between the two stints in St. Louis, he played only 13 games, hardly much of a sample size.
The Cardinals liked Cannizzaro, particularly his booming throwing arm, but they had a glut of young catchers who were prospects, including a 19-year-old Tim McCarver. Faced with the impending expansion draft, in which new teams in Houston and New York, would select players from the existing teams, the Cardinals could not protect all of their young catching. They left Cannizzaro available and watched him become property of the Mets.
During the expansion draft, the Mets had taken three catchers, including veteran Hobie Landrith. But Landrith couldn’t throw, prompting manager Casey Stengel to turn to Cannizzaro, whose strong arm discouraged opposing teams from running so frequently. Cannizzaro threw well, but he also struggled with passed balls, and didn’t hit at all. The Mets demoted him to Triple-A Jacksonville for a spell, before bringing him back for a second look in late summer. He compiled a .268 batting average in his second stint, raising his season average to a not-so-terrible .241 in 59 games, but without any power.
As a member of the Mets, Cannizzaro also drew some recognition because of the difficulty that Stengel had in pronouncing his name. Struggling with the long Italian name, Stengel called him “Canzoneri,” which was apparently close enough for young Chris to understand. For the rest of his days in New York, he remained Canzoneri – at least to Stengel.
Cannizzaro hoped to become the Mets’ No. 1 catcher during Spring Training in 1963, but a foul tip caught his bare hand in the very first exhibition game and resulted in a broken finger. In a strange way, Cannizzaro believed that the injury actually helped his career. Forced to undergo rehab at minor league Buffalo, the young catcher received regular playing time and through repetition, improved both his hitting and his catching.
In 1964, he returned to New York fulltime to platoon with left-handed hitting catcher Jesse Gonder and delivered a .311 batting average and a .739 OPS, by far the best marks of his career. Responding to Stengel’s claim that he could throw but couldn’t catch, he showed vast improvement in his ability to block pitches and keep balls in front of him, reducing his passed balls totals. At the very least, Cannizzaro seemed like he was capable of being a productive platoon player, based on the strength of his catching and his improved work as a hitter.
By 1965, Cannizzaro was one of only four Mets who remained from the team’s inaugural season of 1962. The Mets decided on a huge role for Cannizzaro, making him the No. 1 catcher. That turned out to be the wrong move. Not ready for the job, Cannizzaro flopped, hitting .183, drawing a mere 28 walks, and hitting no home runs. At 27 years old, he was supposed to be in his prime, but he was instead at the crossroads of his career.
As much as Cannizzaro didn’t hit that season, his catching and throwing continued to receive praise. After all, he led the National League by throwing out 53 per cent of opposing basestealers. During an interview with the Sporting News, Lou Brock was asked about the catchers who made it most difficult for him to steal bases. “As far as the toughest receivers,” Brock said, “Cannizzaro makes [every stolen base attempt] close even when you get a good jump.”
Even with such praise, the Mets moved on from Cannizzaro just before Opening Day in 1966. They traded him to the Atlanta Braves for outfielder Don Dillard. Cannizzaro would never play in a game for the Braves, instead playing the entire season at Triple-A and never receiving the call to Atlanta. That winter, the Braves sent him to the Boston Red Sox as part of a minor deal for pitchers Julio Navarro and Ed Rakow.
“As far as the toughest receivers, Cannizzaro makes [every stolen base attempt] close even when you get a good jump.”
Cannizzaro’s time in Boston turned out to be shorter than his expedition to Atlanta. Sometime in February, before the exhibition season even began, the Red Sox traded him to the Detroit Tigers in what is now dubbed an “unknown transaction.” The Tigers hoped that Cannizzaro would become Bill Freehan’s backup that spring, but he did not make the team, instead spending a full summer in Detroit’s system. He then moved on again, this time traded to the Pittsburgh Pirates for outfielder Mike Derrick.
In the span of two seasons, Cannizzaro had spent time in four different organizations, but without appearing in a single major league game for anyone. His career spinning out of control, Cannizzaro desperately needed some stability. He would find some in Pittsburgh – eventually.
At first, the Pirates sent him to their affiliate at Triple-A Columbus, where he spent the first half of the summer. In August, the Pirates brought him up and made him their backup catcher, supporting another strong defender in Jerry May. Cannizzaro played respectably, hitting .241 and compiling an OPS of .740, the latter a respectable figure for a backup catcher. The season was also notable for his milestone first home run, coming in his fifth full season in the major leagues.
In light of his acumen as a quality catcher and intelligent player, it made perfect sense for Cannizzaro to remain in the game. The Braves hired him as bullpen coach, while also giving him a chance to work with their young catchers. After the 1978 season, he moved on to the California Angels, first as a coach and then as a minor league manager. He hoped to eventually earn a major league managing job, but the opportunity never came. Instead, he did good work developing prospects in the Angels’ system, including future standouts like Tom Brunansky and Mike Witt. He also helped out his former teammate in San Diego, Randy Jones, by becoming a longtime coach at the former pitcher’s instructional camp.
In his later years, Cannizzaro was diagnosed with lung cancer. After a lengthy battle, he succumbed to the disease in December of 2016, but not before the Padres honored him for their service to the team. As part of the All-Star Game festivities in San Diego, the Padres formally recognized Cannizzaro as the first All-Star representative in the franchise’s history.
It was a nice gesture on the Padres, who likely knew that Cannizzaro did not have long to live. When he took the field at Petco Park, he was frail and thin, his body clearly showing the effects of emphysema.
Like a lot of fans, I’ll prefer to remember Cannizzaro the way he was on his 1975 Topps card: Smiling and vital and still in the prime of his life. And let’s not forget those gaudy, surreal colors that Topps draped him in, making the card such a memorable one. It’s a card that makes you want to stare at it a little longer, while remembering a smart, tough player who left us not too long ago.
Bruce Markusen is the manager of digital and outreach learning at the National Baseball Hall of Fame