1927 A's field team with seven future Hall of Famers

Written by: Craig Muder

It was a lineup built for Cooperstown – when Cooperstown had not yet become the home of baseball’s Hall of Fame.

It would take another three decades before they were all enshrined, but seven of the game’s greatest players took the field at one time for the Philadelphia A’s on June 11, 1927.

Athletics manager Connie Mack filled out a lineup card that day that started with five future Hall of Famers against the Tigers at Philadelphia’s Shibe Park. Leading off was Eddie Collins, followed by Zack Wheat, Ty Cobb, Al Simmons and Jimmie Foxx.

Wheat and Cobb were finishing out their brilliant careers with the A’s, while Collins was in his second stint with the A’s at the end of his big league days. Simmons and Foxx were beginning stints in Philadelphia that would power Mack’s second A’s dynasty of the late 1920s and early 1930s.

Hall of Fame Membership

There is no simpler, and more essential, way to demonstrate your support than to sign on as a Museum Member.

Later in the game, Mickey Cochrane entered as the Athletics’ catcher. And Lefty Grove relieved starter Howard Ehmke in the sixth inning.

Incredibly, the seven future Hall of Famers were unable to produce a victory as the Tigers won 6-5 behind another future Hall of Famer, Heinie Manush, who had three hits and two RBI.

The A’s were a Cooperstown “prequel” in those days, regularly fielding lineups with multiple future Hall of Famers. In 1928, Tris Speaker replaced Zack Wheat on the A’s roster and was part of a May 24 game with the Yankees that featured 13 future Hall of Famers – the most of any regular season game in big league history.

Collins, Cobb and Mack were all on hand on June 12, 1939 when the first Induction Ceremony was held in Cooperstown. Cochrane and Grove were elected to the Hall of Fame in 1947, with Foxx (1951), Simmons (1953) and Wheat (1959) all elected in the 1950s.


Craig Muder is the director of communications for the National Baseball Hall of Fame and Museum

Mack breaks up second A's dynasty, trades Cochrane

Athletics catcher Mickey Cochrane was sold to the Tigers following the 1933 season as Connie Mack broke up his A's dynasty.

Jimmie Foxx pitched in for Phillies during war-torn 1945 season

While major league rosters were ravaged by war, Hall of Fame slugger Jimmie Foxx helped out the last-place Phillies by spending the final months of his career on the mound.

Grove, Cochrane began Hall of Fame careers together

Future Hall of Famers Lefty Grove and Mickey Cochrane both debuted in the big leagues for the Athletics on April 14, 1925.

Simmons’ unorthodox stance led to Hall of Fame

Al Simmons' unusual approach at the plate produced a .334 career batting average and a plaque in Cooperstown.

Mack breaks up second A's dynasty, trades Cochrane

Athletics catcher Mickey Cochrane was sold to the Tigers following the 1933 season as Connie Mack broke up his A's dynasty.

Jimmie Foxx pitched in for Phillies during war-torn 1945 season

While major league rosters were ravaged by war, Hall of Fame slugger Jimmie Foxx helped out the last-place Phillies by spending the final months of his career on the mound.

Grove, Cochrane began Hall of Fame careers together

Future Hall of Famers Lefty Grove and Mickey Cochrane both debuted in the big leagues for the Athletics on April 14, 1925.

Simmons’ unorthodox stance led to Hall of Fame

Al Simmons' unusual approach at the plate produced a .334 career batting average and a plaque in Cooperstown.