#CardCorner: 2002 Leaf Mike Piazza
Hall of Fame staffers are also baseball fans and love to share their stories. Here is a fan's perspective from Cooperstown.
As prodigious a hitter as Mike Piazza was for teams like the Los Angeles Dodgers and New York Mets, it’s hard to find much in his career with the Florida Marlins that could have contributed to his election to the Hall of Fame. Hey, there’s only so much that you can do in the span of five games. Five games, 18 at-bats, no home runs. One week of the season. That’s it. That’s how much time Piazza spent with the Marlins in May of 1998, after being traded from the Dodgers and before being re-routed to the Mets in two historic trades.
Why did Piazza spend such little time with the Marlins? In 1998, just one year after winning the World Series, the Marlins found themselves in full rebuilding mode. In acquiring Piazza that May, the Marlins were able to shed several big contracts, including those belonging to Bobby Bonilla, Gary Sheffield and Charles Johnson. They also felt that they would be able to turn around and trade Piazza quickly, this time picking up several young players. So after one week with the Marlins, general manager Dave Dombrowski sent Piazza packing, shipping him north to New York for three prospects: Outfielder Preston Wilson and pitchers Ed Yarnall and Geoff Goetz.
In retrospect, that doesn’t sound like much of a haul for a Hall of Fame catcher. And it isn’t. Goetz never made the major leagues. Yarnall never did play for the Marlins, though he was part of the package eventually sent to the New York Yankees for Mike Lowell, who became a valuable third baseman. Of the three players in the Piazza deal, only Wilson put together a significant career in the major leagues. He would become the Marlins’ center fielder, finish second in the Rookie of the Year voting in 1999, and hit 31 home runs in 2000 before moving on in another trade and putting up some gaudy offensive numbers for the Colorado Rockies.
In spite of Piazza’s all-too-brief career in Florida, at least one collector is making a dedicated practice of finding every known baseball card that shows Piazza wearing a Marlins uniform. The collector’s name is Jerry Dworkin, a passionate fan from Irvine, Calif. He has managed to find over 120 different cards, ranging in years from 1998 to 2005, which show Piazza wearing the teal, black, and white of the Marlins.
Dworkin admits that his collection if something out of the ordinary. “I can’t deny it is obscure,” Dworkin told The New York Times. “I’m not a baseball expert. I’m just a run-of-the-mill guy who got caught up in the oddity of the situation, someone as great as Mike Piazza being on a team for just five games.”
In 2015, Hall of Fame Library Director Jim Gates made the Museum’s curatorial staff aware of Dworkin. Not long after, Hall Curator of History and Research John Odell called up Dworkin and inquired about the possibility of loaning some of his cards for use in the Museum's new exhibit Whole New Ballgame. The curators creatively used baseball cards as one of the themes within the exhibit, which details the history of the game from 1970 to the current day. Dworkin generously agreed to loan 30 of his cards for at least one full year.
In total, Whole New Ballgame features 72 baseball cards, spanning the decades of the seventies, eighties, nineties, and the new millennium. Among the 72 are 24 cards from the Dworkin collection, which are featured in a single exhibit case. The exhibit opened in November, with Dworkin among those in attendance. A few months later, Piazza and his wife visited Cooperstown and viewed the cards in the case. The couple even took photographs of the Dworkin display. To put it mildly, Piazza was stunned that so many cards of him with the Marlins could have been produced given his ridiculously short tenure in Miami. Perhaps it’s a sign of just how widespread baseball cards have become within our popular culture.
Piazza used that hitting style to great success, initially with the Dodgers over his first six and a half seasons. (It’s no wonder that Ted Williams, one day watching a teenaged Piazza take swings in the batting cage, predicted that he would hit well enough to make a career of it.) But it’s interesting to note that Piazza’s career almost ended before it started. So discouraged by his fortunes playing in the minor leagues, Piazza went home at one point, fully intending to retire. Former Dodgers standout Reggie Smith, by now a coach in the organization, visited Piazza and talked him out of retirement. Smith (the subject of an earlier Card Corner) and Dodgers manager Tommy Lasorda were perhaps the only two people in the organization who believed that Piazza was a prospect. If not for Smith, Piazza’s career would likely have stalled forever.
Encouraged by Smith, Piazza returned to the minor leagues, and eventually made his way to Los Angeles. He loved the Dodger experience, but contract talks stalled in 1998. With Piazza on the verge of free agency, Dodgers ownership bypassed GM Fred Claire and sent Piazza packing.
Piazza’s ability to hit with such force, both for average and power, remained evident after he joined the Mets in the middle of the ‘98 season, though his New York tenure did not begin well. In fact, for the first few weeks after joining the Mets, Piazza struggled so much that he heard boos at Shea Stadium. The whispers began that Piazza would not sign long-term with the Mets, but would instead high-tail his way out of town via free agency. Then came the barrage in July, August and September. In 109 games with the Mets that season, Piazza batted .348, hit 23 home runs, and slugged .607. With Piazza catapulting the offense to a new level, the Mets won 88 games and placed a strong second in the National League East.
Only in 2003 did Piazza start to show some decline, as injuries limited him to 68 games. Yet, he resumed being a fulltime player over the next two seasons, making two more All-Star teams before leaving the Mets as a free agent. Piazza signed with the San Diego Padres, where he hit well for one season before moving up the coast and finishing out his career with the Oakland A’s in 2007.
Few fans outside of San Diego or Oakland remember much about Piazza’s time with those teams. Given that he spent even less time in Florida - seven days out of a career that lasted 16 years - it might be difficult to find even a few Marlins fans who remember much about Piazza’s time there. But there is no doubt that he did play in South Florida. The proof is evident in those 120-plus Marlins baseball cards, 24 of which have found their way to Cooperstown.
Bruce Markusen is the manager of digital and outreach learning at the National Baseball Hall of Fame